An old nickname for newspaper advice columns was “The Agony Aunts.” The columnists were always women (with the occasional male writer having a female byline), and the letters were always written by people in agony from their problems. I read a lot of these advice columns, mostly online, and I’d like to share my observations with you (both of you).
Some columns have made the transfer online and some haven’t. After Ann Landers died, her two editors took over her column and renamed it “Annie’s Mailbox.” Apparently, even though Eppie Lederer wasn’t the first Ann Landers, she intended to be the last, hence the name change from “Ann Landers” to “Annie’s Mailbox.” Her column has not transitioned well. Rather than have its own website, it’s at http://www.arcamax.com/anniesmailbox. It seems so stuck in providing advice suitable for a family newspaper that it’s not relevant to the current world. Most of their advice can be summed up in the words, “Go see a counselor.” It’s stuck in the 1970’s.
“Dear Abby” has done only slightly better on the web. Written by Jeanne Phillips, the daughter of the original Abby, Paulline Phillips, who was the identical twin sister of Ann Landers, it’s on the web at www.dearabby.com. It only gives the publication dates of the column and isn’t searchable by topic, but people can use email to write in with their problems or to comment on others’ problems. It’s an improvement. However, much of the advice seems to be only one step up from “see a counselor.”
Compare and contrast these two with premier advice columnist Carolyn Hax at the Washington Post (www.washingtonpost.com). She’s using her website presence in a number of really terrific ways. First, she has an interactive chat every week. People can write in with their questions, and she can write answers of any length – she’s not limited to the newspaper word count. The writer can respond live to her answer. Other people can respond live and she can respond to those people. Then, she takes some of the best questions and the interactive comments and creates newspaper columns from them, which are both online and syndicated in papers. She also writes fresh columns for the papers as well, and these are posted online. She posts separate questions for people to answer for each other, and when she’s on break she lets her readers step in to comment on questions. Her work is accompanied by very clever cartoons from Nick Galifianakos, who is also her ex-husband. And sometimes she uses her pulpit to raise money for the fight against ALS – Lou Gehrig’s disease – which killed her mother.
I love Carolyn Hax’s work. She is sensitive and insightful. She tackles different problems than what’s in Dear Abby or Annie’s Mailbox. While the older columns seem limited to “my husband doesn’t pay attention to me” Hax answers situations that are more modern or more complex, from the young woman who doesn’t want to go canoeing on a second date, to the woman who wants to keep a child that resulted from a rape but her husband wants her to have an abortion. Because Hax can answer people online, she can post things that might be too troubling for a daily newspaper (one couple can’t seem to bond with their newborn baby) or too revealing (you have no idea how many people have colleagues with really disturbing bathroom habits). The best part is that Carolyn Hax rarely uses the “see a counselor” answer unless she really must.
I also love columnist Cary Tennis, who is taking a break right now but who is usually at www.Salon.com under the column “Since You Asked.” His column is searchable by topic. He is a great and lyrical writer who is also an admitted alcoholic in recovery and who has faced substantial problems in his life. Tennis’ writing is strange and beautiful and he writes at great length, something he can indulge in online. My favorite column is when he responded to a woman who wrote about continually dating losers, but who was now in love with a man who stole, and she asked if he could change. At first, in his answer, Tennis seems to be addressing the initial question, whether a thief can change, but slowly I came to realize that Tennis was asking her if *she* could change, or if she would continue to date losers like this thief. Brilliant! I wrote a card to Cary Tennis, wishing him recovery from his cancer surgery, and then I bought his book. I look forward to his return when he recovers and I miss him.
There’s one final columnist I must comment on: Dan Savage at www.thestranger.com. He started out as an angry gay man who wanted to give terrible advice to straight people in order to make the point that gays got terrible advice from straight columnists. Then he developed compassion for straight people and started giving them real advice. His column, which is also syndicated in independent papers, is hilarious and troubling at the same time. He answers his letters at great length, something that non-independent papers couldn’t make the room to do. He answers questions that are astonishing in their breadth and which are disquieting, to say the least. Reading Dan Savage, I realize that I had no idea of the list of fetishes that some people desire. Electrical stimulation! Plushy sex!
Dan Savage has invented interesting concepts, like GGG, which stands for Good, Giving and Game, and which should be required of any sexual partner. Another catchphrase of his is “DTMFA” which he uses when people write about dating people who should be dumped immediately. (You can look it up.) He was also so annoyed at conservative senator Rick Santorum that he had people invent a new meaning for santorum as a word. If you google the senator, you’ll find this meaning first, before any mention of the senator, and, trust me, you won’t be able to hear his name ever again without having a very disturbing image come to mind. If Rick Santorum tries to run for a national office, like president of the United States, this word will be popularized worldwide. Since I don’t like the senator’s beliefs, I’m happy to see this. Finally, Savage popularized the use of the word “Saddlebacking” to mean Christian teenagers who participate in anal sex but who still call themselves ‘virgins.’ You’ve got to love a columnist like that!
There are other advice columns, to be sure – Dear Amy, Dear Prudence (begun by the daughter of Ann Landers), Miss Manners, and Marguerite Kelley come to mind – but in my opinion Carolyn Hax, Cary Tennis and Dan Savage are the best on the net.
That’s your thought for the day from the Dubmeister.